Courtesy :www.motifinvesting.com
How
well do you know the differences between growth and value investing? Want to
determine if one of these strategies is suitable for your investment goals?
Let’s explore the principles of value and growth investing as well as the pros
and cons of each of these renowned and debated investment strategies.
THE FUNDAMENTALS OF VALUE INVESTING
Studies
have shown that value investing has done better over time compared to growth
investing.But it should come as no surprise that exceptions can occur and
under-valued companies aren’t always winners.
What’s
the fundamental concept of value investing? The framework was formed in the
1930s by two finance professors at Columbia University, Benjamin Graham and
David Dodd.
The
basic idea is for investors to identify and purchase companies that the markets
have undervalued. If and when the markets adjust upwards to the true valuation
of those companies, value investors can earn profits on those price increases.
Cheap Prices Don’t Necessarily Indicate
Good Value
Keep
in mind, value investing isn’t about buying every stock that has fallen or is
priced low. After all, low share prices can be due to legitimate reasons such
as underlying issues with a company’s financial health and prices may remain
low if solutions aren’t put in place.
Value
investors look for companies with strong fundamentals that the market hasn’t
fully reflected in the price. They analyze a company’s intrinsic value by
looking at various aspects such as its cash flow, earnings, book value, and
business model, looking for clues that the current stock price is undervaluing
its full worth. A few guidelines that some value investors utilize to select
investments include:
•
D / E ratio < 1
•
PEG ratio < 1
•
Market Cap < Book Value
•
Cash > Market Cap
•
Current assets at least two times current liabilities
Now
let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of value investing.
Pros of Value Investing
•
Value investors can take advantage of devalued assets when others are
panicking.
•
The hype and herd mentality do not have much of an effect on a value strategy.
•
Day-to-day price fluctuations and market volatility are not much of a concern
to value investors because they are focused on the value of a business instead
of external factors.
•
Value investors can experience steady and consistent gains that may outperform
benchmarks such as the S&P 500.
Cons of Value Investing
•
Value investors may lose out on larger returns due to searching for companies
with a margin of safety.
•
The under performance of a company’s share price could last for years or may
never rise to the investor’s estimate of fair value.
•
There may be a lack of liquidity due to the stock’s under performance or low
market cap.
•
It can be difficult to determine if a stock has bottomed out or could continue
falling further down.
•
Finding investments can require a lot of time spent on research and analysis.
THE BUILDING BLOCKS OF GROWTH INVESTING
Thomas
Rowe Price, the founder of T. Rowe Price Associates, has been dubbed by many as
“the father of growth investing.” Price’s growth philosophy was based on
investing in companies that he believed would grow faster than the economy and
inflation.
Some
of the aspects Price looked for included well-paid employees coupled with low
labor costs, limited competition, protection from government regulation,
earnings per share growth, consistent high profit margins, and a minimum 10%
return on invested capital.
Diamonds In The Rough
Growth
investing is typically focused on a company’s potential down the road, and not
so much on its current share price. Growth stocks also tend to be younger
companies that reinvest their earnings into the company instead of paying
dividends and are identified as growing significantly faster than their
competition (aka Growth At A Responsible Price). They may also be a part of
industries such as technology that are experiencing fast expansion.
Examples
of guidelines that some growth investors follow when selecting investments
include:
•
Historic earnings growth. For example, a minimum of 7% earnings per share (EPS)
growth for companies between $400M – $4B.
•
Companies with an expected 10-12% earnings growth rate over the next five
years.
•
Industry leaders that have beat pre-tax profit margins for five years.
•
Steady or rising ROE.
•
Expectations that the stock price can double in five years.
Here
are some noteworthy pros and cons of growth investing investors should
consider:
Pros of Growth Investing
•
Successful investments may appreciate much faster than the overall market by
the very definition of growth investing.
•
Investment selection is focused on attractive companies with above average
earnings and sales growth.
•
Investors can gain exposure to cutting edge industries that are rapidly
evolving and are exciting to watch.
Cons of Growth Investing
•
Higher risk and volatility.
•
Dividends are uncommon as most growth companies reinvest their earnings.
•
Time intensive to evaluate the credibility of various growth projection
estimates.
•
Valuations could be much higher than the market average to reflect projected
growth that may never materialize.
Two Sides Of The Same Coin
If
you don’t find yourself strongly preferring value investing to growth or vice
versa, the good news is you don’t have to choose one over the other. Some
investors choose to diversify and apply both methods to their portfolio’s stock
selection.
Warren
Buffet is known for not associating with one specific strategy and stated in
his 1992 Chairman’s letter, “…the two approaches are joined at the hip: Growth
is always a component in the calculation of value, constituting a variable
whose importance can range from negligible to enormous and whose impact can be
negative as well as positive. In addition, we think the very term “value
investing” is redundant. What is “investing” if it is not the act of seeking
value at least sufficient to justify the amount paid?".